SHOULD WE GO TO MARS?

[OPINION ★★★]

SHOULD WE GO TO MARS?

Future Mars colonists playing with children on Mars, a place they call home.

(P1) “Let’s not move to Mars,” writes Ed Regis in the New York Times. “First, there is the TEDIOUS business of getting there. Using current technology and CONVENTIONAL chemical rockets, a trip to Mars would be a GRUELING, eight- to nine-month-long NIGHTMARE for the crew. Nine months is a long time for any group of people to be traveling in a small, closed, packed spacecraft. … In addition, there will be persistent mechanical noise and vibration, sleep disturbances, UNBEARABLE TEDIUM, TRANCE STATES, depression, MONOTONOUS repetition of meals, clothing, routines, conversations, and so on.”

(P2) That’s true, of course. It’s also true, as Regis notes, that Mars itself is INHOSPITABLE: Cold and dry. In recent years we’ve discovered that Mars has more water than we once thought, but it is still not much water. There’s oxygen, too, but it’s not freely available in the atmosphere; you have to EXTRACT it.

(P3) Regis writes in response to a number of recent PROPOSALS — most notably from tech-adventurer Elon Musk — to colonize Mars anyway. Musk isn’t the first to make such plans. But he has unique CREDENTIALS: He’s a very smart guy, he’s a very rich guy, and he’s already building working spaceships.

(P4) So going to Mars raises three questions: (1) Can we do it? (2) Even if we can do it, is it too hard? and (3) Even if we can do it, and it’s not too hard, is it worth the trouble?

(P5) The answer to question one is “yes.” We can send people to Mars. We already send robots to Mars, and have done this so often that it’s barely even NEWSWORTHY.

(P6) The answer to question two depends, to some degree, on what “too hard” means. Regis talks a lot about the personal DISCOMFORTS involved in a Mars trip, but exploration is always difficult and uncomfortable. People who like ease and comfort should stay home.

(P7) As for question three, well, that’s the easiest. Yes, it’s worth it. If human beings become a multi-planetary species, we become harder to wipe out. If Musk’s ultimate goal of a million colonists living on Mars in a SELF-SUSTAINING way BEARS FRUIT, then even CALAMITIES that would WIPE OUT life or civilization on Earth, like a major nuclear war or ASTEROID impact, will no longer be EXTINCTION-level events. That’s a pretty big deal.

(P8) But I think there’s an even bigger reason to settle Mars: Earth civilization has become boring and INBRED. Back in the 1960s, people talked about the development of a “GLOBAL VILLAGE,” but village life can get AWFULLY STAGNANT, especially when there is nowhere else to go. A Mars society, developing at a distance from Earth and in a different environment, would bring useful diversity to human culture.

(P9) So, CONTRARY to Regis, I think a Mars colony would be a great idea.

WORDS: 469

SOURCE: http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2015/09/24/glenn-reynolds-mars-colonize-explore-musk-nasa-column/72672032/

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS:

If you found the passage difficult to read or had problems understanding specific words or idiomatic expressions, please discuss them with your tutor. The following discussion questions should be answered in your own words and with your own arguments.

  1. Briefly summarize the content of the article in your own words.
  2. Do you think that, 20 years from now, there will be colonies on Mars or the moon?
  3. Do you think that a Mars colony could survive for a long period of time without receiving supplies from Earth?
  4. What sort of people would be attracted to the possibility of living in a Mars or moon colony?
  5. Do you agree with the CONTROVERSIAL statement that “Earth civilization has become boring and inbred”?

EXPRESSIONS TO PRACTICE:

What do the following expressions mean? Practice using each expression in a sentence; extra points if you can use it in conversation.

  • Trance state
  • Self-sustaining
  • Bear fruit
  • Wipe out
  • Global village

Cambly Practice Button

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s